Al Shabaab Governance – peer-reviewed paper published

Featured

How does the insurgent Somali Islamist movement Al Shabaab govern the populations it controls, and what are the implications for Somalia and the international intervention there? This is the subject of my article published by the Canadian Journal of African Studies on 18 July 2025.

Here is the link to the final manuscript as accepted by the Journal, and following is the abstract of the paper.

Presentations and echoes

I will discuss this paper as part of the presentation on my current research at Leiden University on 24 September, in a closed session to which LU staff and students are invited.

I’m organising a seminar on this topic at the Center for International Studies of Sciences Po (CERI) in Paris in the second half of October (precise date and location to follow). The seminar will be presented and moderated by my colleague at the CERI Hélène Thiollet.

An article based on my research was published by the New Humanitarian.

I had the pleasure to discuss this paper with Guido Lafranchi, researcher at the Clingendael Institute, and look forward to other discussions with experts!

Note: the banner image is from a 2018 map depicting areas of influence. Al Shabaab = green. Not much has changed since then.

Looking for Arawelo’s Palace

Erigabo/Ceerigaabo, 14 August 2026

Arawelo is a mythical Somali queen. She is the guardian spirit of my frankincense and myrrh essential oils company 2Mages. I heard there was a place supposed to be her palace near Erigabo (Ceerigaabo in Somali) and have long wanted to see it. Today, Friday, I had a day off, and I went to see it. I was curious if I could find any archaeological evidence that her palace really was here.

Locals know about this place and my driver could find it without a problem. We diverged from the road between Erigabo and Maydh after the Karin checkpoint and drove along a stony path through the brush, up to an altitude of 2080m. We stopped next to a pile of stones along the roadside: this was supposedly her palace. Men throw stones on it, making the pile higher, and women put ‘flowers’ (meaning anything green ripped from a nearby tree or bush) because Arawelo is remembered differently by both genders. Women remember a magnificent, wise queen who empowered women, while men remember a queen who castrated male prisoners and whose grudge against all men, including her husband, grew during her reign. Today an overtly assertive Somali girl is called ‘an Arawelo’.

Did Arawelo really live? I assume most legends have a basis in reality, when they are told as historic stories – not for example stories of the Gods. Moreover, increasing evidence is emerging that the Northern Somali coast along the Gulf of Aden shared in the prosperity of the early Southern Yemeni and Ethiopian kingdoms, roughly from 1000 B.C.E. to 500 C.E. Historic evidence that the resin trade flourished in that period is abundant; why would frankincense and myrrh only have come from ancient Yemen, as is often supposed? The Periplus of the Erythraean Sea, written by Greek sailors in the 1st century C.E, gives accurate descriptions of ports along the Somali coast that were already in use for a long time. The Al Madow mountains that stretch from Northern Sanaag to North East Bosaso, and the Al Miskad mountains in Puntland further towards the tip of the Horn of Africa, have always been prime production areas for both resins. If one removes the racist bias in Euro-centred historiography (‘Black Africans cannot have had high levels of culture in the past’) then there’s no reason to doubt that the northern Somali coast participated in the wealth of that period. Archaeological evidence, such as Sabaean (ancient Yemeni) or ancient Hebrew inscriptions and the presence of stone towns in this mountain range, increasingly supports this view.

A trip in the 15th Century BCE to ‘the Land of Punt’ to obtain frankincense, myrrh, ivory and other valuables is documented on the walls of the palace of the Egyptian Queen Hatsheput. There is ample reason to believe that Puntland is meant, despite the mentioned racist bias among Western archaeologists. A King and a Queen with their two sons and daughter are depicted greeting the Egyptian expedition leader on the coast of the Land of Punt. Going further back, the rock art at Laas Geel in Somaliland (3000 BCE) suggests that this region used to be much greener, and had a more varied fauna than today, besides showing high levels of abstract artistry. In an even more remote past, DNA research suggests that genes associated with the Cushitic people may have their origin, some 26,000 years ago, in this same northern coastal region of Somalia – now Eastern Somaliland and Puntland.

For a description and analysis of pre-colonial Somali history, see chapter 2 of my PhD.

The headdress contains little depressions which may have been filled with (gem)stones in the past, suggesting an aristocratic lady – perhaps Queen Arawelo?

I have earlier described some statues presented to me, supposedly found in the Somaliland province of Saahil, that must date from the pre-Islamic period. This all leads me to believe that Arawelo is likely a historic queen from the first millennium before Christ. The Somali archaeologist Sada Mire told me that Arawelo is simply the Somali version of the Queen of Sheba, called Bilqis by the Arabians, just like Makeda is the Ethiopian version. The Queen of Sheba would have reigned around 1000 BCE, in the times of King Solomon/Suleiman. What is very likely, in any case, is that the source of Arawelo’s mythical wealth and power would have been frankincense and myrrh, traded at that time with ancient Egypt, Persia, the Phoenicians and probably already China and other locations along the later Silk Route.

Somalis are curiously reticent to consider that there was anything of value in their culture before they were touched by the light of Islam, equivalent to divine grace. All Somali clans trace their ancestry to the family of the Prophet Muhammad; before that, they believe, there was nothing in Somalia but some dark-skinned ‘Dir’ people whose women intermarried with the prophet’s male descendants, thus forming the Somali people. They have incorporated the very racist view Arabs historically have of black Africans, seen as natural slaves that may be redeemed by Islam, as the story of Bilal suggests. Valuing Somalia’s pre-Islamic past is tantamount to idolatry, in this religious view. If one unearths a finely executed statue of that past, many Somalis consider it should be quickly destroyed.

The historic evidence Somali historians, anthropologists and archaeologists uncover about pre-Islamic Somalia is thus largely ignored, or at least not integrated into the national narrative. Just like in Gulf States. However, as Professor Hussein Bulhan points out in a book documenting the ‘social amnesia and triple heritage of the Somali people’, the ancient Somali folk beliefs live on in the Somali unconscious despite the double repression by Islam and Western rationalism. This explains why men throw stones at the supposed remains of Arawelo’s palace while women lay flowers – they still respond to this ancient identity.

This heap of stones is supposed to mark the location of Queen Arawelo’s palace

The 2-man police escort, driver and drone operator accompanying me dutifully threw a couple of stones to scorn this evil queen who would not submit to men. I had wanted to bring flowers, but could find none in Erigabo. So I did like the locals, and composed a bouquet of broken off branches and a few flowering plants, and laid it on the pile of stones. My travel mates did not make fun of this womanly behaviour, but their presence didn’t allow me to sit in meditation, as I desired; I did a very quick one, trying to connect to the spirit of the place.

We then used the drone to scout around the area. I sought to know in which direction I should start exploring the site. There seemed to be heaps of stone and puzzling straight stone lines everywhere and the drone couldn’t read the elevation or slope of places; so I started wandering around the forest, even managing at one point to escape my escort, who resorted to the drone (unsuccessfully) to find me.

I walked around quite a bit in the forest surrounding the palace. I was misled by finding what I first thought were the remnants of ancient walls. Later I understood they were quite recent constructions by Somali environmental organizations to stop soil erosion. Still, the site reminded me of the ruins of ancient towns, partially because of the ubiquitous presence of chipped stones – the same ones used to build the soil erosion retention walls – and partially because the site is perfect for a town. It overlooks the fertile plain to the South, is nestled just beyond the ridge of the escarpment that leads down to the Gulf of Aden to the North, and commands a strategic view over what is still the main road threading its way down this escarpment to the natural harbours of Xiis and Maydh. The former is easily identifiable as Mundu in the Periplus of the Erythraean Sea. The gentle slopes of this entire stretch of forest would have been a magnificent site for the construction of a large town.

As the Google Earth image above shows, the site is also exceptionally green to Somali standards, and pleasantly high up in the mountains, escaping the unbearable heat along the coast. It is not surprising that the British built a colonial residence near the escarpment edge (in olive green in the image above). The British presence here makes it less likely that there were any remains of a town here. They would have noticed. The British were keen amateur archaeologists, and in the 1930s a colonial cartographer described the ruins of stone towns he had discovered in British Somaliland; no mention was made of a town here. On the other hand, dense vegetation does obliterate all signs of human activity above ground after 3,000 years, and no excavations have been attempted.

Whether there was a palace here for Queen Arawelo or not, one should be built here, as a testament to the strength of Somali women. And next to it, 2Mages will build a distillery for the resins of the frankincense and myrrh trees that are endemic to this coastal mountain range – fully operated by women, such as those from the cooperative Beeyo Maal from whom 2Mages buys its resins.

A Poisoned Gift? Israel’s Recognition of Somaliland

This is a translation (by Claude.ai, revised by the author) of an article I published in The Conversation France on 30 December.

Israel surprised the world by recognising Somaliland on Friday, 26 December. What are the reasons behind this unexpected announcement, and what outcomes is it likely to produce?

A Diplomatic Anomaly

The republic of Somaliland, formed in 1991, is independent in all but name, yet Israel is the first sovereign state to recognise it. For all other countries and international organisations, Somaliland remains under the authority of the Somali state, from which the republic seceded after a war with genocidal characteristics in the late 1980s.

Today, Somalia’s federal government, established with international support in 2012 after decades of civil war, is beset by attacks from Al-Shabaab and the Islamic State, suffers from corruption on a record scale and experiences persistently high levels of political instability. Federal Somalia still lacks a constitution, universal elections and several of its constitutive regions refuse to submit to the federal authorities. By contrast, Somaliland is a democratic and stable haven, with its own constitution, a reasonably functioning electoral political system, its own currency, and an army.

Google  Earth view of Berbera port
The UAE in 2017 entered into a multi-billion$ deal with Somaliland and Ethiopia to develop the port of Berbera (above right) and transport infrastructure – the Berbera corridor – to rid landlocked Ethiopia from its dependence on Djibouti for shipping. A military base in and around the airport (below left) was also part of the deal but never constructed. Courtesy of Google Earth

President Abdirahman Irro was undoubtedly in need of good news. After his victory on 13 November 2024, his government became bogged down in the clan conflicts it had inherited and made little progress on critical fronts such as youth employment, economic growth, and inflation. Following Israel’s announcement, jubilant crowds took to the streets of Hargeisa, Somaliland’s capital.

Continue reading →

Participation à l’émission “En Somalie : Al-Chabab, un Etat parallèle”

Je suis intervenu dans le programme ‘Cultures Monde’ de Julie Gacon sur France Culture (Radio France) le 12 novembre 2025 pour parler de Al Shabaab et le défi qu’ils posent au projet de gouvernance transnationale par la communauté internationale.

https://www.radiofrance.fr/franceculture/podcasts/cultures-monde/en-somalie-al-chabab-un-etat-parallele-2038579

It’s time to resurrect pan-Africanism

This essay challenges conventional narratives that portray African statehood as either a neocolonial instrument or inevitable elite capture by examining how early independence leaders envisioned building states rooted in traditional self-governance within a pan-Africanist framework. But Western powers systematically suppressed African political innovation through violent intervention, the United Nations system and Bretton Woods institutions, making sovereignty conditional on conformity to rules that entrench Western hegemony. African economies were subordinated into raw material export dependence while African elites developed sophisticated adaptation strategies that kept them in power through redistribution of external support. Today, contemporary African youth movements are rediscovering suppressed political alternatives, realizing that authentic sovereignty requires breaking these patterns of extroversion by combining traditional self-governance with regional integration—a vision that remains threatening to global orders dependent on African subordination.

Some of the early inspirers of pan-Africanism, including Americans. From left to right, 1st Row: Patrice Lumumba; Marcus Garvey; Malcolm X; Assata Shakur; Kwame Nkrumah. 2nd Row: Audley “Queen Mother” Moore; Huey P. Newton; Amílcar Cabral; Robert Sobukwe; Omali Yeshitela. Image source: African Skies blog.
Continue reading →

Book presentation: Het Continent van de Toekomst

On 18 September I will engage the author Daaf Borren in an interview at Boekhandel Douwes in The Hague, at 19:00, in a session open to the public. You are welcome!

Daaf Borren’s book ‘Het Continent van de Toekomst: Jongeren over Africa” explores what young (mostly educated) Africans think about their own continent, its challenges and how to resolve them. It is an energizing book that keeps the ‘Africa Rising’ discourse at a distance, and describes how many young people refuse victimhood narratives, while remaining critical about (neo)colonial patterns of domination.

One of the themes that struck me was the revival of the pan-Africanist ideal among young Africans desperate to get rid of corrupt elites held in power by Western extractive and security interests.

Banner image: part of Frantz Zéphirin 2007 – The Slave Ship Brooks as photographed at the 2022 Venice Biennial

Exploring a new approach to development

Governments of rich countries are increasingly reducing development budgets. The massive cuts by the current US administration to USAID, amounting to a sudden reduction in global aid budgets by over 20%, are echoed by cuts in other traditionally generous donor countries such as Germany, the UK, France, the Netherlands, Sweden, Switzerland and Australia. Although both development and humanitarian aid budgets are hit, the following text focuses on development assistance.

Continue reading →

Working for the FAO in Afghanistan

From November 2023 to July 2024 I served as FAO Afghanistan’s Head of Communications, Strategy and Resource Mobilization. I plan to write about it and will edit this post soon. For the time being, here is a short movie shot by Barmak Akram that we edited together into a 6 minute teaser.

It follows me as I travel through Northern Afghanistan speaking with farmers about climate change and what can be done to adapt to it/mitigate its effects.

Barmak is a talented and versatile filmmaker; he shot this on a new iPhone and barely intervened in my activities (except by fixing and removing lapel mics and occasionally asking me to repeat a movement or introduction). He managed to catch most of his footage on the fly. We’d like to make a full length movie on climate change in Afghanistan. Any producer interested can get in touch with him (or me).

YouTube player

Is It Time to Recognize the Taliban Government?

Robert Kluijver. Published in The Conversation (France): December 1, 2024 and in The Conversation (English) on December 29, 2024.

Other language versions of this article were published in the World & New World Journal in Arabic, Russian, Spanish and German.

Is it justifiable to continue not recognizing the Taliban government, which has been in power for more than three years? This stance does nothing to improve the situation of Afghan women and prevents the international community from fully engaging with other critical issues playing in the country.

Selfie by the author with two senior Taliban officials (Director of International Trade and Head of Fairs and International Exhibitions)
Continue reading →

Publication de chapitre sur l’enquête en zone de conflits

Ensemble avec Emmanuel Al Miah et Dércio Tsandzana, j’ai écrit le premier chapitre du livre ‘Enquêter en Terrain Sensible’ (Presses du Septentrion). Le livre examine les difficultés inhérentes aux études de terrain dans les zones liminaires – soit parce qu’il y a la guerre ou d’autres types de violence, soit à cause des politiques institutionnelles d’acteurs qui sont habitués à la discrétion, soit encore à cause du positionnement du chercheur face à son objet d’enquête.

Un grand merci aux directeurs de l’ouvrage pour l’initiative qu’ils ont pris, voici il y a deux ans, et leur patience pour mener ce projet à sa fin. Les autres contributions, y compris l’introduction à la première partie du livre par Roland Marchal, sont aussi très intéressantes.

Notre chapitre décrit comment on peut faire, malgré les difficultés, des recherches dans les zones de conflit, en prenant la Somalie, l’Irak et le Mozambique comme exemples.